Fans of Netflix’s acclaimed drama series beef They have recently expressed disappointment and dissatisfaction with the casting choices for season 2, which are considered to be “predominantly white.” The show gained huge popularity in 2023 for its portrayal of the complex lives of Asian American characters, especially Danny and Amy, and won numerous awards and honors.
“BEEF” Season 2 revolves around two couples at odds.
• Charles Melton & Kylie Spaeny
• Jake Gyllenhaal & Anne Hathaway pic.twitter.com/lsQYsjSuKh
— Movie Updates (@FilmUpdates) February 26, 2024
Although originally intended as a limited series, news of a possible season 2 caused mixed reactions among fans. While many were excited about the prospect of more episodes, others expressed concern about the reported casting decisions. According to reports, creator and executive producer Lee Sung-jin has cast actors Charles Melton, Cailee Spaeny, Jake Gyllenhaal and Anne Hathaway for the upcoming season, which will focus on the conflict between two couples. It is said to be under consideration.
Also read: ‘Beef’: Anne Hathaway and Jake Gyllenhaal reportedly join season 2 cast
The dissatisfaction among fans stems from a perceived deviation from the show’s original focus on the Asian American experience. Some have wondered why the production team chose a predominantly white cast, especially given the show’s initial focus on exploring the personal struggles and aspirations of Asian Americans.
On social media platforms like X, fans voiced their disappointment and skepticism, highlighting the importance of representation in media. One user expressed confusion at the change in casting choices, given the show’s thematic roots in Asian American identity and the pursuit of the American Dream. Another user lamented the tendency for Asian American filmmakers to find success with diverse storytelling, but for subsequent projects to feature predominantly white casts.
This is what I mean. The whole concept of Beef is that Asian Americans struggle through anger and insanity to achieve the American dream, and Season 2 will see this theme explored. Will it be…with a predominantly white cast?
— Oscar winner Lily Gladstone (@devoidofhopes) February 27, 2024
It’s not my job, but Asian American filmmakers really have one hit and white people boom 😭😭😭
— Issa (@Foutanienne) February 26, 2024
Agree.The background has a lot to do with the Asian American experience.
— Ones (@Yewande92) February 27, 2024
I’m happy for Charles, but how did he go from having an entire Asian cast to being the only Asian lead?
They don’t seem to see anything wrong with whitewashing the show. pic.twitter.com/bI1a97Dgnz— Elizabeth🦇 ATLA era (@Elizabeth_XXSJ) February 26, 2024
Critics of the questionable casting decisions worry that season 2 will dilute the show’s original message and fail to accurately represent the Asian American experience. They emphasize the importance of authentic representation in storytelling, especially stories that explore themes of identity and social issues.
Despite the backlash, fans continue to hope that the production team reconsiders their casting choices and stays true to the show’s original vision.
Also read: Prince Harry documentary goes to competing streaming service despite Netflix deal
